Aadha Hai Chandrama – Blooper

Certainly many of us heard this song “Aadha hai Chandrma raat aadhi” from 1958 film Navrang by V Shantaram.
And many, in particular old-timers, would remember the actual scene. If you have not then you can search for the song on the YouTube.

With all due respect to that great man he was in his field VS committed a big blunder during the picturization of the song.

lyricist Bharat Vyas, when he wrote “Aadha hai Chandrama” what should be having in his mind is that the Moon is half illuminated by the sunlight. The day is, therefore, either the first quarter or the last quarter of the Moon

One can be sure that by those lines the lyricist did not possibly mean that the angular diameter of the moon was half nor that the Moon is broken into two equal parts and only one half is presented to the ‘observer’.

The Raat Aadhi signify the time when the scene is enacted and it is the midnight.

Putting these two together the only possible direction where the moon can be seen at this time is at the horizon – either the moon is rising, if it is last quarter or is setting if it is the first quarter.

AND what do we see – a crescent moon two or three days before or after the new moon phase.

I suppose the people are lost in the song and no one seems to be bothered by astronomical blooper.

Well check out this link for first and last quarter phase of the Moon – click here.

Advertisements

About skytonight

I am the present Director of Nehru Planetarium of Nehru Centre Mumbai, India I like to talk about astronomy and sky observations to general public.
This entry was posted in Short articles and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Aadha Hai Chandrama – Blooper

  1. Hi Arvind,
    Thats what i have been taking an example for telling people about bloopers in cinema/arts wrt astronomy!! Another one is once again in a song ‘Jhilmil sitaro ka aangen hoga, rimjhim barasta sawan hoga” written by Anand Bakshi in Jeevan Mrityu (1970)
    there are so many, may be we can compile these and share.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s